drbond
Responses from drbond
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @pindac LOL! Most thoughtful comment out of left field…for the win! | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @terry9 No need to apologize. Your first impression was more correct: different tonearms use different materials, andtheir sonic impact would be interesting to discern. Of course everyone knows that you neeed to set up the tonearms properly wit... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @rauliruegas So far, very few Audiogon members have expressed an ability to compare tonearms, which leads me to my conclusion: very few on this forum have actually compared tonearms, which rationally only leaves dealers, who, of course, are bias... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @thr1961 Thanks for sharing your experience with your tonearms. @whart The purpose of this thread isn’t necessarily to improve my system. Given my limited experience, I found it rather odd that no one really commented on tonearms, as I’ve fou... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @rauliruegas Yes, the standard pivoted tonearm has a 1-1.5 degree tracking error. The linear tracking tonearm that I have mounted (Reed 5A) has a 3-4 minute tracking error (which is 1/15-1/20 of a degree); I don't know if it is this lower trac... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @lewm While, theoretically, you are correct about comparing tonearms (or anything, for that matter, as no one is even the same moment to moment); realistically, assuming that you have a cartridge that doesn't resonate poorly with the tonearm, ke... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @mijostyn Yes, I would agree, that, all else being equal, a LT tonearm should best a pivoted tonearm; however, there are all sorts of other variables in the equation, such as materials, bearings, etc. Thanks. | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @terry9 Interesting statements about natural fibers and tonearm composition. Do you have listening experience comparing various natural fibers (by which I assume you mean wood?) with carbon fiber or magnesium or other element on a similar base?... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @mijostyn While at recognize that the linear tracking tonearms would theoretically offer a better soundstage, experience can occasionally defy theory…which is why I won’t dismiss others’ experiences, even though it may defy logic and theory, esp... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms Dear @rauliruegas To address your points: I presently have at least 5 MC cartridges. I enjoy each of them, and each has its own strengths and weaknesses, and I do have a favorite, but that’s for another thread. The SAT and Safir seem to have t... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @rauliruegas I really enjoy testing and comparing different equipment. It is an expensive hobby, but yields intellectual satisfaction of what sound can sound like. I would be interested in testing and comparing many tonearms; however, the main d... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @lewm How does the Viv compare to the Reed and the Tri-planar? Have you been able to play those on the same TT with the same cartridge enough to formulate an opinion? | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms It seems like much of the conversation has moved towards the technical aspect of tonearms, as opposed to experiential comparison, which I suppose very few have. However, if we discuss the technical components of tonearms, does the supposed sonic s... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @alan60 @tomic601 can you compare your Viv Labs / Porter tonearms to others that you have played that might be more common? What does it do better, and what does it do worse? What do you attribute its strengths and weaknesses to? (It’s not that... | |
| Comparison of sonic qualities of some tonearms @rauliruegas Your statements presume complete knowledge of a subject. I suppose it could be analogous to someone who has driven a Toyota, Lexus, Nissan, Infiniti, Honda, Acura, Ford, Dodge, and Chevrolet commenting how all cars are pretty much t... |