Do I need to replace all my tubes at the same time

I think tubes should always be replaced at exactly 3:02 PM. So the answer is yes.

I think tubes should always be replaced at exactly 3:02 PM

Standard or daylight time?

"Standard or daylight time?" UTC, of course...

Seriously, you have to replace all of your toobs at the same time or else you will break the magic spell.

Even more seriously, it does depend - on the amp and the level of granularity in setting bias, etc. but if you're even asking this question then you are not totally sick/obsessive (yet) and therefore no, you don't absolutely have to replace all tubes at the same time. You would ideally have all the tubes degrade on a coordinated schedule but since they typically do not the best thing is to look for "savings opportunities" and to acquire sufficient stock to handle these as they happen. This is not something to obsess over - you can keep track of "tube hours" but in the end do you care more than anything else about that or do just enjoy that sound and want to hear more?

Stanwal, I disagree. It is impossible to make a statement like that without knowing what amp the OP is using. In amplifiers where pairs of tubes are biased from a single pot it is crucial that the tubes are matched. In this case where tubes are not matched it will shorten tube life and cause a rise in distortion.

It probably depends on which tube has failed in what type of amp. If the tube that's failed is an output tube in a push-pull amp where it's ideally part of a matched pair, then you might want to replace both output tubes with a matched pair for lowest noise.

If it's a preamp tube, or a phase inverter or something, then, no, just replace the failed tube.