Streaming vs Physical Media


I have a decent digital front end with a Lumin U1 Mini (w/ external power supply) and a Border Patrol SE dac.  Have some CDs, but no transport.  Would a CD transport sound better than a streamer of similar quality/price?  

mdonda

Unless you have a large number of CD's, or very rare music on CD (which is doubtful), I'd go just with streaming and not spend it on a CD player. I myself did have a large number of CD's (600+) and went with a Bluesound Vault and burnt them to the hard drive, and it also had streaming with it. Now I have gone up to an Aurrender. I do not find either stream or CD to be better then the other, so unless you have a good reason to copy the CD's you have, sell or give them away and spend the extra money you save not getting a CD player again on a really good streamer. Just another opinion, but I have been there and for my collection of CD's, it made sense to burn them and have streaming for anything I didn't have. Hope this is helpful.

@deadhead1000

 

Personally, I just can’t do that. Perhaps my age, and the ‘need’ to have physical media. Dunno.

As example, I have the Jerry Garcia Band live recording from 1990, recorded at Club Front.

I have it on my original double cassette I bought back then (still have it, and a Nakamichi tape deck), have it on CD, and also a rip of the CD on my server, also on Tidal if I want it there….and just bought the 4 1/2 LP box set that was recently released.

If I want to listen to it, I grab the vinyl first, no doubt about it. Then, maybe the CD, Or even the cassette which sounds great still. The only time I stream it is if I’m feeling extremely lazy, or listening on my bedroom system without a TT.. The vinyl is bar none the best choice SQ-wise.

That said, yea, I listen to all formats, and all are important to sound good to me regardless.

My two bits....

 

I definitely get better SQ from my CDT, but I own maybe 400 CDs. Streaming Tidal gives me millions of choices, so I spend far more time listening to Tidal.

 

 

Term "Streaming" used to be dedicated to music you don't own.
I use computer as server for the the music playback.  IMHO it can sound better than CD/Transport.  Transports operate in real time being able to read particular sector only once and in case of failure have to derive missing data from the error correction or to interpolate. Cheap computer drive ripping CD can read the same sector hundreds of times util proper checksum is obtained and this can also be verified by the checksum of whole CD.  I transfer this bit-perfect data over wi-fi, making anything on computer side (speed, amount of RAM, playback program) irrelevant, since only 100% bit perfect data gets to the other side of WiFi bridge. Up to this point it is only bit-perfect data (no timing involved).  What happens next, how this data is delivered to DAC decides upon sound quality.  It can be better or it can be worse than CD/Transport, but it is cheaper and more convenient.   I still have physical CDs because I like tangible media and because it is required by RIAA copyright rules. The fact that I can easily make multiple backups gives me sense of security and longevity of my music.

As for streaming services like Tidal - I tend to be old fashioned, but who knows - using server also sounded foreign to me at first.

Similar set up to some here Audiolab CDT 6000, Denafrips Ares 2, onto Vincent Hybrid pre / power to Audio Physic Sitara 25's. Recent change to Lindemann Limetree after much experimentation with Lumin, Bluesound and Aurender leaves me unable to say whether stream or CD consistently sounds better. However if pushed I'd say CD by an absolute fraction. For everything else however streaming is the way to go.