Boutique or Big Brand?


Good evening everyone! I am looking at new speakers in the $5k, maybe $6k range. My electronics and room dimensions are on "my system" posted on my profile so I won't repeat them here. I currently have Tekton Impact Monitors, but feel they do not have a good low end (I posted my review on another post so won't bore everyone here). That said, they were the best I could afford at the time and above 40Hz sound good to me.

Now I am ready to upgrade and am faced with a decision... Do I go boutique with a bigger pair of Tektons, or maybe the Salk Song3 A or BeAts; or something from Zu or Devore? Or do I go with a Big Brand like the Sonus faber Sonetto V, B&W 702, or Focal Arias?

I have heard the Tekton, Sonetto V, and B&W 8-series (not the 7 in my price range). I want a slim tower because I feel a lot of them have the same footprint as a pair of standmounters and have better bass extension.

So, what are the benefits of boutique over big brand and vice-versa? It seems in my price range boutique may be the way to go? Thoughts? Any other recommendations?

Because of the pandemic I had to move to a place that doesn't have the audio stores that N.Y.C. and Columbus, Oh. did when I lived there, so I am asking your opinions. Please keep it positive and constructive, thank you.

l1975r

Check out Tyler Acoustics. He has quite a range of options. Excellent customer service and return policy and he's a heck of a guy to deal with. I'm totally smitten with my Timekeeper monitors. His speakers have had some positive mentions in some of the press, mostly from audio shows. 

Repeating expecting different results should be the first thing to come  into your mind...you have some good suggestions and buying used makes more sense to me at your price point...5 to 6 grand used  is a good place to be , no need to compromise on inferior builds

Thank you all for your responses. A lot to think about here.

@missioncoonery &  @mofojo I agree and am tempted by getting a "better" speaker, and a used pair of Sonus faber would allow me to move up the line from the Sonetto V I am considering new, but my concern is that I have been burned before on used online audio (and watch) purchases and this would be a lot of money (for me anyway) to get burned for if it didn't work out again.

I really was saving for the B&W 805 D3. I heard them in Columbus hooked up to the McIntosh MC152, which I have and fell in love. I just couldn't afford them at the time. Now I see used pairs for about $4,500 and am tempted, but I don't want to get screwed again with online used. The new 805 D4 are now $8,500 and out of range. $6,500 for the D3 was doable with saving, but I do not (read shouldn't) want to spend $8,500 on speakers as I have other responsibilities in life.

@audioman58 my room is only 10' x 11' with an 8' ceiling. I know that would normally say 2-way monitor and be done. I feel (and may be wrong) that monitors on stands have the same footprint as a slim tower and If I get a quality slim tower it will probably have a wider frequency response. It is a small dedicated listening room, only the system, some room treatments,  and a chair are in the room.

Nothing wrong with wanting/liking the 805d3. I have heard them a bunch of times and they are fine just a bit bright. Depending on your age a bit of brightness could be good but they are bright enough that bad recordings will be real hard to listen too. Make sure you give them a long listen with the actual music you listen to not just perfect demo music.
 

https://www.stereophile.com/content/bowers-wilkins-805-d3-loudspeaker-measurements

 

Where something like the Revel 226be has near perfect measurements. Their bass extension is light and the -3 db point is 56hz, -10db 36hz so should be fine in your small room which will bring up the sub bass through room gain assuming they are 24” or less from the wall. Not pushing revel just one example of a better speaker for the same money that I have experience with. There are tons of other brands too. 
 

https://www.erinsaudiocorner.com/loudspeakers/revel_f226be/

 

anyway I have owned both brands (B&W, Revel, focal, Thiel, paradigm, Klipsch… etc, ) I think you will end up fighting the B&Ws to sound good. Always tweaking toe in, gear etc where the revels are just a plop and drop and sound great as measurements matter. 
 

If you don’t have dealers music direct has 60 day home trials and free returns I think but read the details. 
 

as for buying used. If it is expensive enough for you wait until you can drive and pick them up or get a one way flight and drive them home. U-haul rentals are cheap, Just get a van. 
 

 

One more sound demo of the B&W 805d3 with the same Focal Sopra 1, different electronics.