Reed 5T Opinions


I think the Reed 5T is a brilliant design. I have seen many negative comments out there but one very positive review.
It is a tangential tracker with only one negative factor and that is that it has a second but isolated horizontal bearing.
The bearing is of the sleeve type which is like a small version of a turntables spindle bearing. There would be essentially no laxity other than in the horizontal plane. It is driven by a very slow linear motor so virtually no vibration. That motor is controlled by a laser aimed at a sensor array.  The tonearm wand has brilliant needle bearings and has almost the same horizontal effective mass as vertical. There is no skating force at all. There are several arm wand materials of various effective masses so you can use any and all cartridges. The arms change out in seconds and you only need to adjust VTF. See it in action here  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Q-Ai35XZsE sorry for the shaky camera. Comments? What am I missing?
128x128mijostyn

@thekong , Very few of us get to utilize equipment in our systems at length if at all before we purchase it and awareness of technicalities is helpful in making decisions as to what you buy or not.

Kuzma makes some excellent equipment. He also makes some not so excellent equipment. Few of us can score a hit every time.

The basic design of the Safir is excellent like the 4 Points. Its effective mass limits it to a small number of very low compliance cartridges. Mr Kuzma's assertion that you can run cartridges with a resonance at 3 Hz would be true in a perfect world but, it is not. Records are not perfectly flat and turntables are not perfectly quiet. There is plenty of very low frequency noise that would energize a resonance that low. I have done this experiment. For yuks you should try it. You won't break anything. Just be ready to use the lift.

@ dover, there are many people who are very capable of analyzing the design of a turntable without having built a single one. By your own argument you are obviously not one of them. Instead of attacking me personally why don't you just explain why I am wrong. Usually, when you see attacks like this it is because the individual is incapable of having a discussion about the technicalities of an issue. Your analogy of the car door totally fails. The door is not suspended by a spring. Although it has detents to hold it open at certain points it will not spring shut when you open it and let it go (unless you are parked on a hill). By having the counter weight on a spring you just add another resonance frequency. The counter weight moves at the same speed and distance as the stylus it's mass is part of the system and can not be divorced. 

Turntables (unless you are Nakamichi or B+O) are extremely simple devices. There are many people who have built their own turntable. Precision bearings are readily available as are great motors and control systems. Only and audiophile can make such a simple device as complicated as a General Electric GE90.

@lewm , I forgot to mention. Your analysis of the significance of Zenith is right on. We should all go back to spherical styluses and give Wally one less angle for barter. Next will be barometric pressure.

Don't know specifically about the Reed 5T, but I can say from experience that I'm getting great results with a Reed 3P, in conjunction with an Ortofon Windfeld Ti cartridge.  Tracking is fantastic, very clean sound.  Plus, it's beautiful to the eye and in use.  I realize there are design differences among the arms.

The 3P costs around $6K, nowhere near the 5T price wise.

bobbydd,

Thank you for this information.  The 5-T is basically a conventional arm located on a rotating base that allows for near perfect tangency and eliminates the offset angle which means no skating force.  It is good to know that the basic design of the arm is good.