Need highly transparent detailed amp---how does Pass XA25 compare to Gamut D100/D200 MKIII


Giving up on the SET amps.  I don't want to replace another expensive tube and the heat from 805 tubes is a warm weather deal breaker.  Considering the Pass XA25 but maybe the Gamut and its higher power rating would be a better option and allow a greater range of speakers to be used.  Can anyone comment on how the Gamuts compare to the XA25 in terms of detail retrieval and transparency (and any sonic differences).  Many thanks!
lcherepkai
@lcherepkai  45 watts is a lot of power for an SET! Its very difficult to get good bandwidth in an SET with that sort of power, but its pretty easy with a more conventional Push-pull amplifier, and the power tubes are often much less expensive! Our M-60 makes about 60 watts into 8  ohms, but the power tubes for both channels together are only $420.00 and we warrant them for a year. If you had a H/K Citation 2 (refurbished) they make 60 watts also, and the output tubes are only about $140.00 total. That amp is also wider bandwidth than almost any SET, and its certainly lower distortion.

My point here is there are a lot of tube amps out there that may well do the job that could make more power, less heat and less distortion, and very likely sound better at the same time with a lower output tube cost. One limitation nearly all SETs face is that if you really want to hear what they are about, they should be played on a speaker that does not require that they go over about 20% of full power. This is to prevent the higher ordered harmonics from showing up- those harmonics will cause the amp to sound 'dynamic' and they will also cause it to sound 'loud'. With most push-pull amps, the usable power is much greater- often well over 90%, so you get a lot more usable amplifier power for your investment.



atmosphere-----thanks for all the insight.  Truly useful info here is a rare commodity.  And funny you should mention the H/K Citation II as I had a pair of a modern rethinking of that classic design in monoblock form, the VAS Citation II's.  These really are quite nice and, although of the same power rating, were able to drive to moderate levels a pair of BG Corp 520 loudspeakers that the SET JAS amplifier could barely rouse at all.  On speakers more suited to them though, the JAS was quite a bit more revealing of the subtle inner details that make music engaging to me.  With Shuguang Treasure 6CA7's, the VAS amps were luscious and quite detailed and always a pleasure to listen through but the JAS just had more insight.  I like tubes in my source (presently a Raysonic 228 and a Modwright Oppo BDP 83SE with the tubed outboard power supply) but otherwise would like to get back to a solid state amp for full time duty.  Thank you very much for the wisdom
@lcherepkai  If you like the sound of tubes, but really want solid state then my first recommendation is for a Pass Labs amp.