2. analog
  3. 1137678090

Will VPI scout or Michell Tecnodec beat my emmlabs

Theoretical question. I have not had a turntable since my Technics SL1200 in the 1970's. I have only 3 new LP's, of alternative artists that I am currently into (bought for auditioning purposes only). Yet, I think I would like to add vinyl to my system: emmlabs CDSD; DCC2; Lamm M1.2 ref amps;Kharma Midi-Grands;Jena Symphony cables. (Perhaps, I am crazy ... given that I don't have a vinyl collection ... yet, a lot of the indie/alternative stuff is available locally or on internet in vinyl ... sometimes recordings are only available as vinyl !!! ... plus, I am tired of worrying about copy control discs that can be a problem ... So, I would like to consider adding vinyl if it can get me past what I have now with digital)

However, I don't want to spend more than 1000-1200 for a table and arm. (Obviously, I will also need a phonostage + cart ? budget ??). I can get a used VPI Scout (6 mo old with 300 rpm motor) for this budget vs. a JA Michell Tecnodec, as two possibilities. I am curious whether any of these tables can allow me to get a significant slice of the benefits of vinyl, without spending a lot of money ? With a reasonable phonostage and cart (not too expensive though), would this surpass my emmlabs. Unfortunately, locally I don't have the ability to trial many tables. There are only 2 high-end dealers (one largely internet-based_, but most of the stuff would have to be bought outright, as demos are not readily available.

Finally, if anyone thought the VPI scout was a reasonable candidate, any suggestions for a decent phonostage and cart that would be appropriate for my associated equipment and allow me to get the most out of that table ? Again, I apologize but I don't have anywhere local to try these things out right now.
thom_y

Showing 1 response by rushton

rushton's avatar
rushton
2,445 posts
 
As Dlwask says, vinyl and digital are just different animals. But then comes into play our respective tastes and priorities as listeners, and therein lies the final answer.

I've listened to systems with a VPI Scoutmaster/JMW-9, Shelter 501 cartridge and Chenin phono stage and I've listened to systems with EMM Labs processor and transport. For my listening priorities, I'd far prefer listening to vinyl on the Scoutmaster setup, even though I recognize the excellence of the EMM insofar as digital playback is concerned.

So, I'd certainly fall among those vinyl fanatics who will say, "Yes, you can match the performance of your EMM gear." But, whether it will sound so for *you* will depend on *your* listening priorities.

And, I fully agree with the cautions not to assume you can accomplish superb vinyl replay "on the cheap" or without an investment of time, care and energy.

Best wishes in your considerations,
More to discover