2. speakers
  3. 178355-11588

Will rebuilt Quad ESL 57s take the place on a great $30K dynamic speaker?

In the ‘90s I lived joyfully with Quad 57s for 10 years. Have always missed them.

Especially since Electrostatic Solutions rebuilds came to light, I have looked for a used pair. My system today is far better than what I had back then.

I was very curious to hear what they would sound like now.

I love my current speakers, but have experienced some fatigue in loud, full passages. And I realized that most of what I listened to was acoustic Jazz and Classical. But with a good amount of Pop singer/songwriter.

The Quads beautifully reproduce solo or otherwise “gentle” music. They are magical with voices. Eg.: Opera that I never got into much is now sublime. And voices in general.

But on something like Peter Gabriel, the fall apart. “So” which was a favorite recording is problematic at best.

I am leaning toward the Quads since they do “moderate” unlike almost any.

But I do miss the dynamics. Bass and treble.

 

 

 

mglik

Showing 1 response by clearthinker

clearthinker's avatar
clearthinker
1,582 posts
 

@mglik    You correctly observe the 57s are missing some punch on gutsy material.  This has always been the case and there is nothing to be done.  Peter Walker conceived them for operation with quieter music such as chamber groups and voices not backed with a big orchestra.  They excel on that.

But on rock and large orchestras on powerful pieces 57s won't satisfy many people.  This kind of issue is why many of us have more than one system.  Horses for courses and you just have to choose which way to go.  It's always a compromise.

 

More to discover