Karls, I learned a lot from your post. Could you explain something I have heard.
Listening to PSB Image 4T with plastic drivers, I was immediately disappointed to hear how much cleaner the sound was than B&W kevlar. But B&W's sales pitch is that Kevlar has benign breakup and plastic / metal etc. doesn't. That is, as the sound wave hits the edge of the driver and ripples back, the kevlar breaks it up while the plastic doesn't. The result is this reflected wave produces sound (which is not musical nor created by the input signal) and mucks up the true signal.
I can verify this as I have heard distortion on the PSB's which I think was due to breakup.
Is there any way to get the clarity without the nasty breakup? I asked B&W about this and they said using an aluminum driver, for example, the designer has to use a smaller driver to push the breakup mode higher and out of the range the driver is designed for. Even still, I have heard nasty ringing on small metal driver speakers.
I don't seem to hear this problem on Thiel speakers even though they have metal drivers and maybe this is because Jim Thiel is so obsessive about his crossover designs.
Would ribbon mid or tweeter drivers solve this problem?
Thanks, this question has bothered me for a while.