I prefer digital sound. The LPs that I buy are limited to ones that either were never issued digitally or were poorly remastered digitally. Occasionally one of these LPs will eventually be digitized and I almost always prefer the digital.
Having said this I recognize that it is possible to get excellent sound from analog. I believe that many listeners prefer to hear the colorations from their analog set up (usually related to cartridge choice)and the sense of ambiance from LP playback, and I think the OP is probably not one of them.
I might investigate the sugar cube.