Why do people say low power amps should be good for bookshelf speakers?


I was in a BB Magnolia recently and they had a McIntosh MHA150 integrated headphone amp that can also do 50 watts per channel to speakers. The sales rep said it "should be good for small bookshelves but its not enough power for towers". 
I've never understood this line of reasoning.  Towers are typically more sensitive than bookshelves. Is there an actual reason a small amp like this couldn't do just fine for towers that are equally or more sensitive than similar bookshelves?
roberthz

Showing 1 response by verdantaudio

It depends.  Many bookshelf speakers are not sensitive but also don't have deep bass response.  When SPLs go up to high levels (and power draw goes high), usually it is at the lowest frequencies (below 40hz).  You will rarely see frequencies above 60hz rise more than 10dB above average volume levels even in the most dynamic music.  

I have speakers here with a frequency response that begins rolling off at ~60hz and 45w is plenty to drive them at reference levels despite having an SPL of 84dB.  If they started rolling off at 40hz, I would be far more concerned and would seek a lot more power.