All that matters is the quality control at mastering and production.
Natural pvc has no colour, additives and black carbon (has conductive properties also) strengthen the lp and make it black and in the long run it would probably last longer. Colouring is a dye nothing more but pleasing to the eye and give a nice alternative, making more desirable some releases. True with clear and coloured ones imperfections are not easily noticed but sonically are equal to the black ones.
I would avoid, for sound quality only, the pictured ones being the thinner.