2. pc-audio
  3. 179645-112119

What is the added value of a streamer over a networked dedicated Computer

Hi

I see lots of sales pitches for streamers as digital sources, and plenty on this site advocating them. I get that they're a purpose-built user interface but, apart from that convenience, including a visual display on the device, (i) do they really deliver better hi-fi sound as a source over a well set up computer dedicated to hi-fibreoriduction (ii) if so, why?

Here's some background to my question(s). I currently use a dedicated Mac Mini with SSD (headlessly) and Audirvana Plus software through a USB DAC. I tend to listen to digital files on external drives (wired connections). Some are high Definition eg Flac, some are aiff ripped from my extensive CD collection. Currently I only tend to use Spotify etc to test if I like music and invest in actual downloads of the music I like.  In day to day use the Mac Mini/Audirvana Plus (virtual) player is controlled using its remote app on an iPad on the same Network. If I wanted I could add high quality online streaming from, eg, Tidal. Whilst that would expand the breadth of music I have immediate access to, it seems to me to add another potential source of interruption/corruption of data flow. The Audirvana software overrides/bypasses detrimental computer audio elements and processes keeping the data path simple and dedicated to hifi audio replay.

So what, sound quality-wise, would a standalone streamer device using NAS or other drive storage and/or online web connection bring to the party? It seems to me it's just a digital device containing effectively the components of a computer with a button (or remote) interface. I understand the old argument that it's dedicated and not doing other things simultaneously and that computers are traditionally electrically noisy environments but I'm currently sceptical that with a dedicated computer, not being used for other purposes, and running a virtual device like Audirvana Plus which effectively switches off internal functions which might compromise sound, this is a real problem. Also it seems that a "dedicated streamer" contains many elements which are effectively computing elements. Note that I have no industry connection or monetary interest from Audirvana or Apple.

128x128napoleoninrags16

Showing 2 responses by 12many

12many
221 posts
 

@yage

I think Yage is on the right track. If the digital data is getting to your DAC and accurately represents the intended song data digital bits should be the same.   Assuming you have a properly functioning dedicated streamer and separate dedicated DAC of good quality - let’s say $500 and over for just the streamer and using wired connection and properly functioning cables, a digital 1 is a digital 1 and a digital 0 is a digital 0. DAC will have differences though. Properly functioning devices correct jitter and Ethernet has error correcting / FEC built in. I know people say they can hear the difference, and that is great and I don't think they are lying, but technically, I don’t know of any reason why some digital bits are better. I would like to see a comparison of the digital data after receipt and processing the the DAC USB to compare the bits between streamers. I always have an open mind.

That being said, computers and their OS tend to be difficult to get working properly, PC’s seem to be the worst. I have read the OS can resample the signal or the digital output of some motherboards can be really bad. I had a USB port on a motherboard once that could barely function for data I/O. You should try a good quality wire connected streamer and see if you can hear a difference. That is the real test, and be sure to let us know.

12many
221 posts
 

This is a great thread with great info. I started streaming on a PC. I have a used Node 2i coming this week to try it out. Fun to try new things.

The exclusive mode/driver/format changes on a PC are a pain so I want to try the node. In defense of the computer, it is nice to have one connected because it allows access to other content. I can watch or listen to concerts or songs on YouTube, netflix, or amazon or other music access web sites. Good way to sample and buy high res songs too.  We were watching a Zepplin concert and it was great. Sound was not high res, but still to listen and watch was fun.  Lots of great content on YouTube with the video - again, not perfect audio, but still good music.  

More to discover