What is meant exactly by the description 'more musical'?


Once in awhile, I hear the term 'this amp is more musical' for some amps. To describe sound, I know there is 'imaging' and 'sound stage'. What exactly is meant by 'more musical' when used to describe amp?

dman777

Showing 4 responses by mapman

Good stuff! That is my interpretation.

If only we could post some notes and a key this thread might even seem musical!

Does it pull me in and make me want to listen to the music and actively participate, or am I presented with a laboratory in which only the truth is heard?

Personally, I think a system is more "musical" when more recordings of music one actually cares about can be enjoyed their fullest. Then the system for playing the recordings is working well and maximizing its value. Again, what one enjoys is a very subjective thing and the details will surely vary to some degree for each.

 

.

Great question!

Well, all music is musical pretty much by definition, eh? Or not.

Musical is a totally subjective term. Practically, it means people like what they hear.

Distortion is the key.

Some people like no or low distortion and hear that as more "musical". Low distortion is a proper objective goal, but "musical" is a subjective term and not the same.

Others may find the presence of certain types of harmonic distortion that does not bother the ears more "musical" because it sounds better or right to them. That’s fine....it’s a totally subjective determination.

If you read up on tube amps you will find that they tend to have unique distortion characteristics that many find more "musical", especially with how the human voice and acoustic (as opposed to electronic) instruments sound. Others not so much

On the flip side, electronic amplification and sources are an integral part of a lot of pop(ular) music. The unique distortion characteristics of tube amplification tends to fare less well there, though there are no absolutes. Both tube and SS amps are capable of producing similar very high quality sound for a cost.

Tube versus SS sound is just one common example where the term "musical" often enters the conversation. All it tells you is what each person prefers ie what their own personal opinion is of what sounds good or not.

.