What is it I'm failing to grasp?


I come across statements here and elsewhere by guys who say 1) their systems come very close to duplicating the experience of hearing live music and 2) that they can listen for hours and hours due to the "effortless" presentation.  

I don't understand how these two claims add up. In tandem, they are profoundly inconsistent with my experiences of listening to live music. 

If I think about concerts I consider the best I've witnessed (Oregon, Solas, Richard Thompson, SRV, Dave Holland Quintet, '77 G. Dead, David Murray, Paul Winter Consort), I would not have wanted any of those performances to have extended much beyond their actual duration.

It's like eating-- no matter how wonderfully prepared the food, I can only eat so much-- a point of satiation is reached and I find this to be true (for me) when it comes to music listening as well. Ditto for sex, looking at visual art, reading poetry or playing guitar. All of these activities require energy and while they may feel "effortless" in the moment, I eventually reach a point where I must withdraw from aesthetic simulation.

Furthermore, the live music I've heard is not always "smoothly" undemanding. I love Winifred Horan's classically influenced Celtic fiddling but the tone she gets is not uniformly sweet; the melodies do not always resemble lullabies. The violin can sound quite strident at times. Oregon can be very melodious but also,(at least in their younger days) quite chaotic and atonal. These are examples on the mellower side of my listening spectrum and I can't listen to them for more than a couple hours, either live or at home. 

Bottom line: I don't find listening to live music "effortless" so I don't understand how a system that renders this activity "effortless" can also be said to be accurate.   

What is it that I'm failing to grasp, here?  


 

stuartk

Showing 3 responses by russ69

I can listen to my system all day long. I'm not at concert levels but it is totally satisfying and engaging. If you can't listen to your system for at least a few hours, you have a problem. 

...whether a system that can be listened to all day long can be truthfully said to accurately  duplicate the sound of live music. Personally, I wouldn't want to listen to live music all day long. 

At full volume about 3 hours is my max but I have my system at very reasonable levels for the last 6 hours and it sounds great. I'll turn it off around bedtime. It's not background music, I'm listening to every note. 

My impression is that the monitors need to be turned up sufficiently to pressurize the rooms. 

My loudspeakers (Triangle) play well at low levels but I also use a sub that is turned up to match the low level. I have to turn it up a notch to fully pressurize my room.