What are the best subwoofers to use with Magnepan 20.1s?


Hello all.  Which subwoofers would give the smoothest response/integration with Magnepan 20.1 speakers?  The rest of the system is Audio research Ref 3 preamp, Pass labs 600.5 amps, VPI ref scoutmaster turntable, Pass Labs XP 25 phonostage, UHA Tape Deck.  Thank you in advance for the help.
powerdoctor

Showing 4 responses by bdp24

If you have a big enough room, there is nothing like a pair of Tympani panels, the T-IV or IVa. Make sure they have been to Magnepan to have their wires re-glued.
+1. Well said johnny, agree 100%. That continuously variable phase control is absolutely mandatory in a sub; the Rythmik plate amps have one as well. That, added to the Open Baffle/Dipole design of the GR Research/Rythmik Sub makes it a particularly good partner for dipole speakers such as Maggies (and ESL's, Ribbons, etc.). Lean, mean, bass machine!

Two points:

- The Rythmik sub plate amp allows for high-level hook-up to binding posts (on the main speaker’s power amp), like Rel’s.

- OB/Dipole subs (such as the GR Research/Rythmik), their figure-of-8 radiation pattern creating a null to each side of the sub, do not excite the sidewall-to-sidewall resonance mode that Monopoles do, therefore creating less of the "room boom" often associated with and attributed to subs.

There is, unfortunately, a price to be paid for those otherwise-advantageous nulls: a corresponding bass cancellation that increases with descending frequency---a 6dB/octave, 1st order acoustic roll-off. Rythmik designer Brian Ding compensates for that roll-off by installing a complimentary 6dB/octave bass boosting "shelf" into the plate amp which comes with the OB/Dipole Sub kit, which counter-acts the roll-off, resulting in bass response claimed to be flat into the teens. Clever fellow.

When using a Magneplanar Tympani as bass augmentation, the panel can be butted right up against a side wall, with a significant resultant benefit: A prevention of the normal dipole cancellation, as the front and back opposite-polarity waves can’t meet and cancel each other, the path obstructed by the wall. That results in the absence of the 1st order, 6dB/octave roll-off inherent in a dipole speaker. Hence, no dipole bass roll-off (at least not from that end of the panel). Free extra output to a lower frequency, with no extra cost, or penalty!