There is a lot of misinformation in the above posts. Just do some searching of archived posts here and on Audio Asylum to get a more accurate background. VPI hasn't helped things by changing their platters from time to time without changing model numbers. Nevertheless, both the 19 Mk.III and 19 Mk.IV started out with composite platters that used lead inserts and a cork damping pad on the underside. The platter on the IV was thicker and heavier. I used the Mk.III platter for many years and always regretted not upgrading to the Mk.IV. By all accounts, it was a significant improvement over the Mk.III platter. After a few years, VPI dropped all of their lead-insert platters supposedly out of concern for their employees who had to handle the lead material, and went to all-acrylic platters. According to some who compared them, the all-acrylic platters did not sound as rich and warm sounding as the prior versions. Much later VPI came out with all-aluminum platters which those with long memories should find amusing since the original 19 series tables started out with all-aluminum platters.
VPI HW-19 MkII Vs. MkIII, how are they different?
I'm considering getting one of these turntables and wonder which sounds better. The MKIII has a lower average book value for some reason. I would greatly appreciate it if someone knowledgable in VPI models would let me know about any sonic differences between the two so I can decide which one to watch for in the classifieds. Also, if there is another VPI model that sells for around $800 used, without arm, that is a better choice than either of these I would like to know what that would be.
Thanks!
Jay
Thanks!
Jay