usb, spdif, or usb to spdif converter


If both a source and dac have both usb and spdif connections, generally speaking which is a better connection, and is it ever advantageous to use a usb to spdif converter over straight usb or coax? It was my understanding that these devices were developed for legacy dacs with no usb input. usb wins over coax in my system (computer based) but I am considering purchasing a converter if that will improve things. Thank you.
majorc

Showing 3 responses by majorc

Many thanks and hope you all had a wonderful Thanksgiving.  I am running a windows 7 desktop computer (a 12 year old gateway) usb output to an idsd micro dac for both music and blu ray movies.  I would rather use a stand alone player.  However, when I compared the computer sound (usb to the usb input of the dac) to the player's sound (coax to the same dac - using a newer sony blu ray player) the computer's sound was MUCH better in every way.  Any thoughts on getting equivalent sound via coax from a player would be appreciated.   

Thank you. After reading the last 2 posts my gut tells me that my computer is a better transport than the sony BR player. Also I am playing rips from the computer's hard drive so that may partially explain the difference.  I power the idsd dac from its battery, not the usb cable, and it does sound better that way.  However, I have heard many times, on this forum and others, that the usb interface should never be inside the dac - hence the reason for my question regarding the usb to spdif converter. My dac is around 7 years old and I'm due for an upgrade - any recommendations new or used up to 1,000 that would best the idsd? One that was recomended was a used monarchy audio M24 but they are hard to come by.       

many thanks - actually I do find ripping too complex and cumbersome - the only reason I am doing it is because the computer sounds so much better than the sony br player -  curious - what is the other (complex) alternative?