Of those, I think VPI has the better reputation and number of fans, but turntable preferences, very like speakers, can be a very personal experience. More than the electronics in my experience.
I'd try to listen to both (and others in that price range) to get an idea of what sonic signature works best for you. I personally have really enjoyed the VPI Classic sound, but after a short time with an HW-19 ended up with a Well Tempered Amadeus, which has since been replaced by a Townshend Rock 7.
I'd try to listen to both (and others in that price range) to get an idea of what sonic signature works best for you. I personally have really enjoyed the VPI Classic sound, but after a short time with an HW-19 ended up with a Well Tempered Amadeus, which has since been replaced by a Townshend Rock 7.