I've sold my footers and record enhancers to many idler type TT owners with plinths like yours. They will completely resolve your issue !
https://www.anvilturntables.com/
https://www.anvilturntables.com/
Turntable and Rack vibration control
I've sold my footers and record enhancers to many idler type TT owners with plinths like yours. They will completely resolve your issue ! https://www.anvilturntables.com/ |
Completely agree. Multiple motors, multiple belts etc. often compounds noise. Many manufacturers bearings produce so much friction they need either large or multiple motors to operate properly. A single AC motor operated with reduced voltage ( only possible with low friction platter bearing) solves many issues with no loss of dynamics. Alternately motors can be isolated enough to prevent most transfer although the belt is still a conduit. Generally the more rigid the belt the more potential for noise to get to the stylus albeit at a higher frequency which is easier to nullify. Often however sound quality improves enough ( micro dynamics/shading/transient Fidelity)with thread type belts that I would still prefer this method. A good heavy platter and oil well bearing will help swamp any noise as will the platter matt. |
Also, I'm not a fan of flywheels. They add unnecessary cost and complexity and add a second often poorly designed bearing. Much better to just add more weight to the platter. Don't get too caught up in the noise issue. Its not that hard to deal with in a GOOD all around design. I would take the 300 rpm motor because I like the larger surface area and grip that a larger pulley provides. Hope this helps |
Sorry but I can't let this one go. Stylus drag is real but has a negligible effect in a well designed turntable. Generally, turntables suffer from way too much torque rather than not enough. Eliminating bearing friction is a better approach than an oversize motor. A great bearing makes a small motor act as it is HUGE. EMT's analagy is loaded with a bit of hyperbole to say the least . Only a crap design will be hindered by stylus drag. |
Get a different bearing and replace the rubber belt with a thread and those issues will go away. It's not the motor torque it's the compliance of the belt and the relatively high friction bearing in your deck. Idlers and directs have their own challenges. Good examples of each sound more similar than different. Cheers |
I'm simply stating my opinion which I believe represents the least compromised design. Having said that I'm a big fan of all turntables, at any price point wether it be belt, direct or idler drive. Furthermore I have experimented a fair bit with high torque motors and found no advantage regarding dynamics and noted a few disadvantages. In my design I am actually able to run the motor at half it's torque rating which netted on the fly improvements across the board. I'm open minded about it however but after a fair amount of testing this is where I've landed. |