Tubes for Magnepan’s.


I think next up on my acquisition list is a tube amplifier. I'm not looking for the be all end all, cause I don’t think there is a definitive "Best", so am looking for as good as I can get for $3-4k.


Because tubes drive speakers so much more efficiently than solid state I am only looking for 40-50 watts to drive my modded Maggie’s, 1.7i's. (Or what you have when you add a new crossover and planer tweeters to 1.7i's.) Maybe 2.7x? I haven’t settled on that yet. And I have some Zu Dirty Weekend's upgraded to the max coming in in 2 months to replace my KEF's.

Anyway, I haven’t had a tube device since my Halicrafter short wave radio, and reviews are not the same as advice from people that own something. There is a Rouge Audio dealer in my area, last I looked, (opps, they no longer carry them), so I may have to go to another market to hear something, or get a try before you buy from a manufacturer or dealer.

You folks have taught me a lot, and I think asking users is the right thing to do on this change in direction.

Thanks in advance.
128x128william53b

Showing 1 response by pickindoug

To preface, I'm the guy that looks for sonic treasure at very reasonable price levels.  First pair of Maggies were SMGa, and while the sweet spot for listening was about 1 sq foot, I was amazed at how good a pair of picture frames with thin plastic film and wire could sound, even if not technically as accurate as my Thiel CS3.5 or Altec 604-8G.  I also restore tube gear, had just finished a Bogen DS265, about 65 wpc, and just for fun hooked it up to the SMGa, which shouldn't have been happy with less than 100 wpc.  The sound was remarkable, the stage, every bit as good as the mega SS amps I'd been running, from a vintage Sony TAN-8250 to Spectro Acoustics 500SR to Classe 25, along with scores of others that didn't make the cut.  Fast forward to this year.  Now have Maggie 1.6QR, and they sound great with the same assortment of SS amps as well as 50-70 wpc from tubes.  Picked up a pair of AES SE-845 monoblocks by Cary Audio.  After a bit of tweaking, they benched at 25 watts into 8 ohms at the onset of clipping.  Although volume constrained vs the big watt amps, they sound remarkable with the 1.6QR.  Edges of bass are predictably a tad softer vs SS, but the soundstage and realism is as good as I've ever heard with these 1.6.  Sitting position is about 10 ft from speakers and the amps still have headroom when musical peaks are hitting 83-85 db.  Going to run through the audio library with this setup before reconnecting the SS amps, just to see what's missing when I do.  Bottom line, try some different tube amps at various wattage levels....you may be surprised.  As far as the admonition that tube watts are different, they're not.  But the transition into clipping is much softer than with most SS amps, and the less edgy harmonic distortion of a tube amp creates the illusion of greater SPL.