Tube Power vs Solid State Power


I continually hear Tube power is more powerful than Solid State Power. IE; “A 20 watt tube amp’s power is like a 60 watt Solid State Amp’s Power” and so on… Is this true ???

I always think of the “What’s Heavier, a pound of Feathers or pound of Rocks story?” A pound is a pound right ? 
Maybe someone could offer some thoughts and explain if this is true or not. 
Thanks
128x128flasd

Showing 2 responses by genovanelli

What that WATT sounded like, when it was used, that's a different story.

THEN not all watts are created equal, ay?


Steve Deckert of Decware uses the motto - "If the first watt sucks, why continue?

I have been a tube amp user for the last 4 years - specifically a flea watt amp. I love the sound, and the 2.3 wpc are BIG watts, in that, I very seldom need more volume for my listening level preferences. But, matching speakers must be pretty efficient - preferably above 94 dB sensitivity. There is so much detail and a lot of space around the instruments. It is very "involving" musically.

But...a short while back, I became interested in early 70’s SS amps, and decided to get one. I ended up finding a '71 Sansui integrated, that had been fully restored. Truth be told, I just loved it cosmetically (AU-222 black face, mini) and really got it more as a novelty than anything else.

Folks - I was ill-prepared for what happened when I hooked that puppy up! Like I stated above, my speakers are high efficiency (open baffles) and the Sansui (18 wpc - 8 ohm) just blew me away. Not only does it crank like the devil, but it sounds spectacular.

It is evident that the level of clarity is not on par with my tube amp, but, to me anyway, the sound can be more natural, and I find myself wanting to come back to it over the tubes more and more.

Anyway, I love both the tubes and the SS, and you really don’t have to choose one or the other - you can have both for a completely different sound. But when I listen to the Sansui, I think about John Peel, saying that a guy was trying to convince him that CD’s were better than vinyl because they had no surface noise. His answer was "listen mate, life has surface noise."

My point (I guess) is that sometimes, the more clarity you have, the less natural it is. After a few years of trying, I finally decided that I did not like high definition recordings (in general) because, what they gain in clarity, they lose in realness.