The Emperor Has No Clothes!!


Read a post the other day where someone characterized a server/streamer as “sweet and tube-like sounding”.  It read like a parody.  Am thinking of starting a company based on tube rectified power supply for network switch.  Crowd funding?

128x128mdalton

Showing 4 responses by tonywinga

This is a jaded bunch. It seems many of you have not had the pleasure of experiencing a well tuned, high end system. Brick & Mortar stores are scarce these days and even then finding a well done set up is rare. Visiting an Axpona is a great way to experience audio systems. Even there, out of the dozens of rooms I visited only a couple of systems stood out for me- and not the most expensive systems. Even if out of reach, hearing a well done high end system can be an inspiration- like watching pro golfers play. Then one can get a sense of what is possible. The first rule of audio: Your system sounds great until you hear something better.

The OP’s system, for example. That is a nice stereo (your cat acts like he owns the place) and a beautiful room. But that wall of glass destroys the sound- only that room looks so good I don’t think I could change a thing in there myself. It’s an example of the compromises we have to make. Still, it is likely difficult to distinguish subtle changes in that room. The room is the most important component in a stereo system.

Think about standing on the end of a long dock on a lake. Drop a pebble. See the nice, perfect concentric rings the waves make where the pebble fell into the water? Now drop a pebble in a small container of water. The concentric rings reflect off the sides of the container and the ripples quickly become a lot of hash. That is what is happening in a listening room. Room design and room treatments absorb those reflections or redirects them to make the room seem more like a lake than a small container. Some heavy drapes would help that room a lot but there goes the view.

And one other thing- leaving a car dirty does harm to the paint. I just cringed when I read that. Automatic car washes are not good for the paint either. Nothing like a sponge, mild soap and a bucket of cold water. I bought my first new car in 1980. I washed it by hand regularly. Everyone said I would soon tire of that. I never have.

Ever wonder how we see black on a white projection screen?  You could say it is confirmation bias.  The brighter the projector and the darker the room, the blacker blacks look on the screen,  The white screen has become the darkest surface in the room.  We can listen to music on an AM car radio (back in the day, the 1960s) and appreciate the song even through the static.  FM radio in the 70s sounded much better- confirmation bias?  Sure it was but powerful enough to leave AM radio in the dust.  Same with the growth of cassettes in cars and then CDs.  

Our senses are comparative.  Confirmation bias is a part of life.  Embrace it.  It’s not a bad thing.  When your system sounds better, enjoy it.  Wondering if the expense of a new gadget is worth it?  Put the old gadget back in.  If the old gadget sounds as good as the new one, great.  Save yourself some money.  But why treat people with disdain for enjoying their systems?  “Illogical”, says Mr. Spock.  Yes, I like the Original series the best.  Confirmation bias because that’s what I grew up with?  Probably.

Thank you for the invitation and likewise if you are ever around about the Savannah, GA area.  I live not too far from there-100 miles from downtown.  Hey, we’ve been known to drive down there for dinner- not much else to do in middle Georgia.  It’s good to get a fresh set of ears to hear our systems.  I stopped listening to my brothers.  They’re just jealous.

Here’s a story for you all regarding the room.  I have my listening room which is quite large but has dormers.  I had some corner traps and a few absorption panels on the front wall behind the speakers.  Now my shop is 30x30 with a drywall ceiling finished in textured spackling.  The walls are insulated and covered with perforated Masonite.  That makes the shop hemianechoic (mostly).  When I sold my Thiel speakers a couple of years back I set them up in the shop with a cheap little bluetooth amp so the buyer could audition them before purchase.  The Thiels sounded amazing in the shop.  I got sick to my stomach because they sounded so good.  This was nuts.   My first thought was cancel the sale but the buyer was already on the way.  I was ready to move my stereo to the shop until my wife talked me off the ledge.  So I went to work on my room.  It took me a couple of months, but I got the room to sound much, much better.  Mainly I had to work on the sloped ceilings but also put absorbers- bass traps in the dormers.  The last issue is signal to noise.  The diffusers and absorbers actually helped with that too.  Still, if I had room in the shop…