I know that I could buy either pair, sample and return if not satisfied, but I'm not thrilled with the expense of return shipping.
For 10% of your budgeted amount, you have the luxury of auditioning two very good speakers, head to head, in you own audio room, with your current components and peripherals. Consider that 10% Fee, and carrying the extra 2K on your credit card for a month, a Down Payment on putting you on the road that has smart written all over it.
If financial reasons are paramount, accept either as a great option and don't second guess yourself. All the best.