Its not the belt. Although it takes some nerve to charge $400 and use the wrong belt. And still not fix anything. So at the very least you have to admire their dedication to overcharging. But you’re right. I don’t know this particular model but they do use some kind of sensor to trigger the lift and return. Probably a photocell, when the arm breaks the beam it triggers. After 40 years its dirty, less light gets through, its gone all SJW on you, now the least little thing and its triggered. ;)
Pull the platter, maybe the base or plinth, look around, see what you can find.
Pull the platter, maybe the base or plinth, look around, see what you can find.