System advice


I’m still a newbie to audio world, but a couple years ago I got Monitor Audio Platinum PL II speakers with XLO Signature cables (good old stuff), Arcam Alpha 9 amp & preamp and Naim CD5 XS with FlatCap XS. Sound was great for me - juicy, involving, deep. But then I was talked into having the whole stack from Naim. I replaced Arcam amp/preamp with Naim NAC XS 152 & Naim NAP 155 XS. I was told it will be an upgrade from Arcam and that having full stack from Naim will provide great synergy.

The problem is.. I almost stopped listening to the music right after this change. There’s something unpleasant in the sound. There’s a lot of details, good resolution but... I don’t feel amused anymore.

Recently I understood that there is no synergy between speakers/cables and amp/preamp. It’s like some sweetness, warm is missing in this sound..

But now I have no idea in what direction I should go. Any advice for a noobie?

 

gabriel123

Showing 2 responses by akg_ca

ISSUE: Change your MONITOR speakers or change your NAIM electronics 

Somebody gave you some dodgy and incomplete advice by ignoring key influencing factors and pushed their fave NAIM bias on you.:

All brand components have their own bespoke sonic signature , That’s why system synergy ( or conversely a lack of it …) is so important when cobbling together a full system. 

NAIM electronics is a fine brand that is one that polarizes listeners. When you do your research , you may find that NAIM’s sound divides the listeners into either a love it or hate it camp. One size does not fit all ….Sure ….NAIM can sound lovely with certain speakers, but yours don’t seem to fit.

My personal audition experience with MONITOR speakers and also my observations with them at audiofests suggests MONITOR is a better suited to avoid  NAIM ( see polarization divide above) . CYRUS and MONITOR were paired at an audiofest I attended a couple of years ago.

Others I would audition are 

  • Sim Audio Moon 
  • Musical Fidelity 
  • Cambridge Audio
  • Exposure
  • Arcam ( you already know how much you liked this ,,,) 

Alternatively…. Yes …. NAIM can be a fine partner with numerous other Brit speaker brands . Think HARBETH, SPENDOR, ATC ….

TAKEAWAY

Go audition alternate stablemates to MONITOR , or conversely audition better pairings  with NAIM . There is no singular silver bullet magic solution in these forums. 

Some drive Fords….some drive Chevys. 

FOCAL speakers and NAIM electronics are the same company now .

https://www.focalpoweredbynaim.com

No small wonder that your buddy suggested the pairing out of one or more of possible reasons:

-possible EZPZ convenience? Dunno

- possible limited audio brand experience …dunno again…,

, or just plain considerable personal bias simply cuz he likes them! but in total who cares now ?


But to carve out 50% of that bespoke synergy match he enjoys, and arbitrarily stapling it to your speakers and then selling it to you blindly was a gross disservice to you.

TAKEAWAY


Resulting fix = a partial or full system replacement for you that is not insignificant to your wallet drain.

Yes, FOCAL with NAIM make a decent enough pairing IMO,….. but regardless, that duo combo never has and still does not stir my drink FWIW.This hobby is very personal journey with a “like” or “dislike” outcome that no post in this forum can predict for you,