I have the same feeling about Y splitters, not very audiophile-ish.
I will not argue the impressions of audiophiles but I don’t believe there is any electrical difference between preamps with two rca outputs and what is accomplished by the splitter. If it feels more audiophile-ish, order the fancier AudioQuest splitters I linked in my first post here. 😎
Consider that you might be over-thinking this.