2. speakers
  3. 150063-43

Speaker Recommendations - from Vandersteen 5As

I have been using Vandersteen Model 5 speakers in my system with excellent results.  I like the open sound, balanced top to bottom sound, sound stage 3D dimension, and having deep bass that is adjustable.  They really have a huge sound that is also very musical.  I used to own Alon V MKII speakers and the Alnico mid-range driver produced a better mid-range sound  compared to the Vandersteens in that one aspect.  That mid-range was just pure magic and the Alons had more impact but were not close to being as balanced of a speaker.  I recently sold my older model 5s because I got a great deal on a much better cosmetic condition Vandersteen model 5As.  To me the 5As just don't sound like my old model 5s.  I have not really had the chance to play around with them that much and my system unfortunately changes in some ways because my Audiomeca CD transport bit the dust.  That was one hell of a great sounding CDT.

I am looking in the $7500 price range and usually purchase used.  I have plenty of dealers in the NYC area that I can visit and people that I know so I will be taking the time to take a look around.  I do like the size of the Vandersteen 5s so that if something I would be considering.  I was thinking of a short list and thought Verity Parsifals, Sonus Faber, Legacy, DeVore, etc.  I tend to focus on piano so I need a speaker that really can produce that sound first before I look elsewhere.  I probably lean towards a musical sound maybe slightly warm, open on top with air.  I can adjust the sound by changing caps and resistors in my components so I guess I just need a balanced sounding speaker with a great mid-range that can also product deep bass.  

Also note that I build my own DAC (separate power supply), preamp (separate power supply) and power amp so I can build anything for any speaker.  Right now my DAC is a DHT design, preamp 6SN7 design and amp is a hybrid 6SN7 design.  My system is dead quiet and the components are reference quality compared to the best that I have compared them to at local dealer showrooms.  I only spin CDs right now through a transport and I am using a Metronome CD1A  transport with a separate power supply.

So knowing that I am in the NYC area, what speakers in the price range should be on my short list to go our and hear?

I probably sound like an A-hole but I would really like some recommendations.  If you are in the local area, I would enjoy the company if you are interested.  I'll buy the pizza and beer!

Thanks and Happy Listening.
bigkidz

Showing 11 responses by gdnrbob

gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
As you are in the NY area, I would contact Audioconnection for a demo of ProAc. Similar to Vandy's but with a British sound that may be closer to what you are looking for.
And, if midrange is your fav, have you thought about electrostatics?
To be fair, what are you using with the 5a's? 
If you are game, I would love to meet up.
Bob
gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
@bigkidz ,
I’m on Long Island. Let’s make a date. I know for a fact there is a good pizza place just down the road.-though Rutt’s Hut isn’t far either.
I haven't heard of GT Audio until now. I will try to listen to a pair.
As you have listed your equipment here,
I will look at your system. I just can't understand why you are having issues with the 5a's.
Bob
gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
@kren0006,
Thanks for posting.
I will keep an eye out for Spendor.
Bob
gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
@bigkidz .
I looked at your system, but see you are using your own (hand built) equipment, and since I don't know how it sounds, it is something I can't comment upon.- Though I would sure be interested in listening to it.😉

I never heard of the  NY Audio Syndrome Audio Group. A quick Google showed nothing. And, I would be interested in joining in, too.

I think Stringreen, and others have made good points regarding the possibility of the drivers/crossovers not being up to spec. 
Stringreen also made a great post saying that you should be able to send back only the amps/drivers/crossovers and save on the shipping. I, too, would have a hard time justifying sending back my whole speaker.
As you are a very capable fellow, removing said items should be a walk in the park.😁
Sorry if the emojis are goofy, but I like to play with them...

Bob
  

gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
Ahh, now that seems like something- not the best situation, but at least a reason for the sound discrepancy. And, like I said, you seem to be a very capable person, so tracing the problem should be easy.
BTW, how can I listen to the components you build?
Bob
gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
Weekends are probably best for me.
It sure would be nice to put a face to everyone's name.
@bigkidz ,
Can you bring some of your equipment, too? Like your DAC?

Bob

gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
I would be interested in comparing your DAC with the Ayre Codex, which I use and know Johnny sells.
Any updates?
B
gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
I stream music from a Bluesound Node into an Ayre Codex.
Currently play quobuz through the Bluesound.
Bob
gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
Are we still on for the 31st?
Bob
gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
I just got back and met with Bigkidz. It's nice to put a face with a name.

We listened to the VLR's, Sub 3's, Belles Integrated, Ayre Codex, Bluesound Combo.
Very nice, but I thought the bass was a bit exaggerated-I don't know if it was the Sub 3 settings or just the room (it got better if I pulled my chair forward). Thankfully, Johnny switched over to an Aurender streamer, and I have to say things got much better. Now, I am looking at Aurender, sigh...😉

@ctsooner .
Have you gotten The Memory Player set up, yet?
I really have to get Sam to look at my Mini and finally get it set up.
Bob
gdnrbob
4,417 posts
 
@bigkidz , 
I am glad you concur.
I don't think I am the most discerning listener, but I do know when I think things are a bit unbalanced.
I also hate to say anything negative, especially when in front of potential buyers.
I need to PM Johnny.
B
More to discover