Soft-dome tweeter damage - NBD or permanently compromised?


I’d appreciate the community’s help untangling a tweeter damage question. I bought a used pair of floorstanding speakers produced by a boutique brand that is well known to the audiophile community. (I’ll keep the name to myself, I’m not trying to call them out.) During shipping, both soft‑dome tweeters were crushed. I used the tape‑and‑pull method to pop the domes back into shape, but I have always understood from others that a deformed tweeter can never perform the same after such damage.

The seller felt otherwise, leaving a voicemail claiming that the tweeters should perform identically once restored to their original shape. Of course, it would be in the seller’s interest to say that, so I resolved to find out from the manufacturer what tweeter was used so I could source replacements myself or ask the vendor to supply them.  When I contacted the manufacturer, I heard back from the owner, who to my surprise said, "I don’t think that will affect the sound if you got them back to where they should be. It’s basically a dust cover anyway....  They’re soft domes. I’ve had it happen a few times over the years. I’ve never heard any problems with it myself."  He offered no specs for a swap.

So I’m stuck. Are soft‑dome tweeters truly unaffected after being crushed and popped back out, or has their performance been permanently compromised? Should I keep listening or hunt down replacements (with almost no information on what to buy)?

Any first‑hand experience or technical insight would be greatly appreciated!

zm

Showing 2 responses by oddiofyl

I would press them for new tweeters.  Tweeters are fragile.  My daughter cranked the volume fully tilt and even though the tweeters looked fine, I thought it didn't sound the same 

I removed the diaphragm and it was clear to me that the driver wasn't right.  All-round the edge was puckered.  It distorted so hard it warped the voice coil a d former. 

They are new speakers , I would push back on that one.  

Would love to know what brand.   That is not an unreasonable request for new tweeters.