smaller speakers for critical listening?


I'm curious whether folks out here think that standmount speakers can reward "critical listening." 

I know that may be a ridiculous question; of course one can sit down with Radio Shack speakers and engage in serious listening, and of course the experience is subjective for all of us. I'm actually asking for subjective responses here. If your goal is a system for critical listening, do you think smaller speakers can do the trick or do you need the bigger soundstage and depth that can come with floor-standing, planar, or electrostatic speakers? 

I'm not asking which is *better* in a given speaker line, the small ones or the big ones, and I'm not thinking about $50k Wilson-Benesch Endeavours or the like. Before the pandemic I auditioned some highly enjoyable standmount speakers in the $5k-$10k range. However, listening for an hour in a store, I couldn't tell whether they crossed the threshold from "terrific sound for a small speaker" to pull-up-a-chair-and-tune-out-the-world bliss.

As you can probably tell, I'm struggling with my room; it's very hard to place big speakers in it. Otherwise I'd buy Maggies or Vandersteens or JA Perspectives, etc, and be happy. And, to repeat, I know that the threshold for critical-listening speakers is subjective. I'm asking for opinions and experiences!
northman

Showing 9 responses by djones51

If you want critical listening in a nearfield setting nothing beats active pro monitors. Genelec, Adam, Focal, Neumann. In a midfield setting larger model of active pro monitors. To augment the bass there are pro subs to match the monitor you choose. 
Around $11-12K you can get Dutch and Dutch 8c. They work in about any room look up the reviews. They are large monitors. 
I notice above headphonedream preferred the Boenicke W5 to Dutch and Dutch . We all have our preference and me telling you which I prefer doesn't really mean much but since some are sharing their preferences I will say I sold Joseph audio Perspectives 2 and kept the D&D, they are amazing speakers. 
To think you need large speakers for critical listening is living in the past. DSP and new waveguides and other improvements in active speakers make them some of the best for critical listening as long as you’re not trying to fill a huge room with them. In my opinion speakers like Dutch and Dutch, Kii, Grimm, GGNTKT are the future . They give simple one box solutions and don’t over power rooms which I think younger people are looking for not to mention their performance is astounding.
I don't think you'll get a consensus. Could I be fully satisfied with small speakers? Probably not. Could I be fully satisfied with stand mount speakers? Yes.