I've been down this "large vs small" speaker rabbit hole a number of times. What I learned the hard way is this: if your room really won't support large/full-range speakers (due to dimensional or placement/decorating issues), then do the following:
-- audition medium to large 2-way speakers (all are far smaller than a full range tower speaker), paying special attention to authority in the mid- and upper-bass, as well as the other audio verites of soundstage, midrange density/resolution, treble, etc.
-- Then combine the selected 2-way speakers, ideally stand-mounted, with a pair of subwoofers, equally carefully selected.
The overall cost should be no more than, and possibly somewhat less than, a pair of full-size speakers.
My vote for the authoritative 2-ways would be the ATC SCM19 v2 (ATCs are killer in every way).
-- audition medium to large 2-way speakers (all are far smaller than a full range tower speaker), paying special attention to authority in the mid- and upper-bass, as well as the other audio verites of soundstage, midrange density/resolution, treble, etc.
-- Then combine the selected 2-way speakers, ideally stand-mounted, with a pair of subwoofers, equally carefully selected.
The overall cost should be no more than, and possibly somewhat less than, a pair of full-size speakers.
My vote for the authoritative 2-ways would be the ATC SCM19 v2 (ATCs are killer in every way).