Single driver vs. mini monitor


I'm putting together a *small* second system (HT and 2-channel). I would like some advice on trade-offs between single driver speakers (Gallo Micro, KEF2005) and mini monitors (Triangle Titus 202, Paradigm Atom/Titan, Ascend CBM170). Does the extra size and tweeter in the monitors result in a better sound? Are these the right speakers for me to be looking at?

Thanks for your help!
jezzholland
Ascends are extremely clear on vocals and I would say are the most practical for your situation. Plus you get bass, and good dynamic range. If you can live with a pure, clean midrange and forgo the rest of the frequency spectrum then single drivers are great. A bigger single driver helps but anything like a whizzer cone destroys the sound IMHO. And my experience with transmission line to boost bass(Meadowlark) is that you get more bass but it's slow and bloated.
Jezz:

The KEF2005 is not a single driver design. KEF calls is a "Q" system, I call it a coaxial. The speakers have center mounted tweeters (where the dust cap on a driver usually is) and a crossover of sorts.

With all things being equal (never happens this way:-) a good single driver design will offer more discernible reproduction of speech (a big plus when listening to movies/TV). The downside being that they do not have the HF extension of most multiple-way speakers that use a tweeter.

Although a fan of single driver speakers they are not always the best choice.

Having played around with building a small 2-channel HT setup for our bedroom over the past 6 months I finally ended up using coaxial drivers (center mounted tweeters) instead of single drivers.

The room (rugs over carpet, comforters, wool blankets, a gaggle of down pillows, stacks of clothing that never get put away, etc.) is so dead acousticaly that for the best overall sound tweeters are needed.

As the system is for HT/TV use only I am now toying with the idea of adding an inexpensive multi band equalizer to the mix (see them quite often @ the thrifts) in order to better tailor the sound to the room. Not a Hi/fi approach, but then it's not a Hi-fi system.

I picked up an old Carver receiver with bass/mid/treble controls which is what gave me the idea. The tone controls on the receiver, though helpful, do not offer minute enough adjustment.
Depending on what are you looking for. I assume you will be using some kind of Subwoofer? If not, Paradigm would have the most bass, and in that case i do not see having a single driver loudspeaker having any advantages over minimonitors mentioned above.