Sim Audio I-5.3 vs Anthem 225 vs Creek Destiny 2


I have no access to auditioning the above integrated amps. I am very familiar with Creek's SE5350 Classic integrated. The Sim and Anthem products I only know by reviews. The Anthem's price at $1595 is very reasonable considering you get a decent MC/MM phono stage and 225 RMS. However for every great review of the Anthem, I have read and heard negatives on some audio blogs about its sound and its unruly volume control. The Sim audio seems like a nice, well built product but I can only afford a used I-5.3; the new Sim integrated at $6000-8000 featured in TAS last month is way beyond my budget. I would appreciate all comments from owners or auditioners of these products. Thank you, Jim
sunnyjim

Showing 1 response by sfar

I don't have any experience with either that particular Creek or with the Anthem but I've owned three Simaudio 1.5's and I can't recommend that amp highly enough.

I bought a black one, traded it for a silver one, sold that one in an irrational fit of frugality and regretted it every day after it was gone. When I saw one of the Limited Edition ones come up for sale I jumped on it and I think I'll have it for a long time.

The build quality of the I-5 is extraordinary, better than anything I've seen in the price range. The feel of the volume control alone is enough to make it worth having around. It's just a beautifully built piece of gear.

Of course, it also sounds wonderful, very transparent without ever calling attention to itself. I've used it both as an integrated and as a preamp paired with a tube amp. I don't think you can go wrong with one.