There are a number of speakers in your price range that are excellent. They will all sound different from one another and from one room to another. The only way to really know is to at least go hear them. Also at audiocircle.com is Selah Audio. Rick's line arrays have received as astounding user comments as either Salk or Vmps.
Btw I am a part time dealer for Vmps so I'm not pushing you away from them, just saying that after hearing so many speakers myself and many different speakers in other peoples systems I know nobody can make a good choice for you but you.
There are many users of B&W speakers that are very happy. I like the sound of B&W myself. They are just way over priced compared to what you can get from one of these small companies. Maggies sound good too but are anemic sounding dynamically to me yet they have a strong following.
You're on the right track. The audio mags don't review alot of speakers that sound outstanding for the money. Go listen to all you can before you buy.