I’m sort of looking at those two as well. Curious to see replies.
19 responses Add your response
here we go again Too bad the Technics looks like Sh!@. And the rumble and vibrstion from that direct drive mechanism on the platter must sound wonderful. Lol @jeffvegas Each Technics is different and if someone prefer wooden plinth then SP20 or SP10mkII can be mounted in any custom made wooden plinth with any tonearm. Slate plinth also possible, even cast iron plinth. Vibration from a platter? Do you know the weight of the Technics platter or Technics turntable itself ? This is not your plastic belt drive toy... Comparing Technics (very well damped) heavy or even superheavy platter to belt drive turntables with lightweight platter is nonsense. And we can put heavy (2.9kg) Micro Seiki CU-500 copper mat ot top of the Technics platter without any damage to the bearings and no effect on torque. Do you really think that several generations of engineers of the Denon, Technics, Victor, Pioneer have no idea what they have been doing for 100 years ? Even a lightweight platter of Denon DP-80 is not that simple if you will look how many layers did they use to design such platter. There is a damping material between the layers. If a Direct Drive could spread harmful vibration to the platter then it would be impossible to make any vinyl record! A master disc lacquer cuts on Neumann lathe with Technics Direct Drive motor under the platter, the cutter stylus above that. Constant argument about vibration from a well designed DD motor that can be picket up by a cartridge is 100% BS ! Before posting nonsense do your search first and read something at least if you don't have (or never tried) a well designed Japanese Direct Drive turntable (no matter what brand). |
Not everyone is a Technics fan. Myself included for my own reasons. Read the OP's thread. He didn't mention Technics, you guys did.... Some people don't even know a better turntables exist at the same price with different type of drive, plinth, tonearm ... Brainwashed by dealers at their shops, or there is another reason - it's really hard to understand sometimes. But any entry level belt drive turntables are very bad and the tonearms on those turntables are very bad too. Why not to mention an alternative before someone will make a costly mistake? Or it will be exactly like you said below: Do you really want a good turntable, or do you have too much time on your hands for doing something constructive. Search audiogon on Rega and Pro-Ject and you will see how many problems with those turntables mentioned by their owners. Others trying to invest more in the same turntable to make it better instead of just buying a proper turntable from the start and forget about everything except for the cartridge. |