Hello all, another interesting thread from Bryon. As a sidebar, after years of casual listening to quite decent Sennheiser HE60 electrostatics through the stock head amp, I recently had an opportunity to hear an all-out custom tube head amp driving current top-model Sennheiser dynamic headphones. For the first time I think I "got it" regarding what headphones can achieve in terms of disintermediating electronics and room affects from the music. The key insight was that I had never heard a headphone set-up that approached my regular stereo in quality. Most audiophiles outside of the "head-case" niche are likely in the same boat. IME the gain in detail and separation out-weighed the loss of natural acoustic space.
On a lark I set about modifying my Headroom line-level processor to the point where I felt that the advantage of the crossfeed process was not off-set by degradations in the electronics that had relegated this unit to storage for some years. Briefly, crossfeed has the effect of shifting forward and tightening images that in normal listening appear furthest to the side and rear. Only images that are way out to the side and rear seem affected. The effect is to make a headphone "sound stage" analogous to the experience of a conventional listening room. So I am inclined to agree with Al, that this more forward sound stage is natural, with the caveat that a process like crossfeed can spook the ear into hearing a natural sense of the room acoustic, while preserving the advantage that headphones have in being unfettered by reflected sound. As with so much in hi-fi, its all about the implementation.
On a lark I set about modifying my Headroom line-level processor to the point where I felt that the advantage of the crossfeed process was not off-set by degradations in the electronics that had relegated this unit to storage for some years. Briefly, crossfeed has the effect of shifting forward and tightening images that in normal listening appear furthest to the side and rear. Only images that are way out to the side and rear seem affected. The effect is to make a headphone "sound stage" analogous to the experience of a conventional listening room. So I am inclined to agree with Al, that this more forward sound stage is natural, with the caveat that a process like crossfeed can spook the ear into hearing a natural sense of the room acoustic, while preserving the advantage that headphones have in being unfettered by reflected sound. As with so much in hi-fi, its all about the implementation.