PS Audio Xstream Statements vs. RSA Poeima


Interesting. I've run Poeima! (original version) in my system for about 5 months. I've been happy with it, but always felt like it was a little "smoother" than I might like. So last week I bought a used set of PS Audio Xstream Statement speaker cables to see what would happen.

I've only listened for an hour or so of each cable, but the very first thing I noticed is a 2dB gain when the PS Audio cables are in. I'm guessing this is due to the Poeima having higher impedence, and I'm also guessing Robert at RSA designed the cable to have higher impedence to help "smooth out" the sound of silver. (Any thoughts on either of these two points is greatly appreciated!)

Anyway, the PS Audio cables seem to be "livelier" without being "brighter." Not sure how that can be, but it's the only way I can think to describe the difference. There is an annoying edge to certain female vocals with the PS Audio, but it seems to image better than the Poeima.

I've listening to each for an hour, comparing the two by listening to a song or two with one cable, then listening to the same song(s) with the other cable. My hands are getting tired of changing the cables!

I still can't figure out which one I'm going to keep. My IC's are all Poeima. Would buying PS Audio IC's likely help me make a decision on which way to go, or am I just spending more money?

Thanks,
Howard
aggielaw

Showing 2 responses by aggielaw

Interesting thought, Thorman. I have been changing cables frequently because I can't really remember how my system sounds once I stop listening to it. Sounds silly, I know, but it is what it is.

Clio, my RSA cables all have well over a thousand hours on them, I've made sure of that. :)

I'm getting irritated by the comparison. I think I'm learning what the phrase "inner detail" means. I suspect it is connected to transparency. With the RSAD cable in, I hear details like the echo in the studio. I barely hear it, if at all, with the Statements. I prefer the RSAD to the PS Audio for Jazz and classical.

So that's it, I like the RSAD better. Not so fast. The reason I started looking into new cables is because there is some coloration with the RSAD, I think. Piano never quite sounds "right" - it's like a little film/haze is in that area. I hear it with electric guitar most of the time, too. Interestingly, the Poeima projected vocals a little more up front than I'd like until I inserted 85Hz filters on the inputs to my amp; now vocals are almost too recessed. Why that filter made that change I have absolutely no idea.

The PS Audio statements are livelier, seem to be a bit "weightier" and I like them better for rock and country, but I know I'm missing that "inner detail" I guess, because I don't get the feeling I'm actually there in the studio hearing the reverberations like I do with the RSAD. The PS Audio reminds me of mid-fi equipment in that it sounds great with material that isn't recorded well or doesn't contain alot of nuances. Not that I'm knocking it for that, because it isn't that the PS Audio Statements are mid-fi quality - quite to the contrary, I think they are remarkable in that they give a solid, well-defined soundstage and the music sounds great. I really enjoy just sitting back and listening to the music with the PS Audio. With the RSAD, I always feel like I'm doing "critical listening" trying to hear all the details the RSAD is capable of throwing at me.

I still haven't figured out how I can call the RSAD both "smooth" and "detailed" at once, but I guess other RSAD owners, at least, know exactly what I mean.

I do think I hear some rolling off in the highs with the PS Audio cables, and I will explore that quite a bit tonight, since the cables will stay in my system for another week while I bring in a new sub (ACI Titan arrives tomorrow) and try to set it up properly over the next few days.

So now I'm wondering if I'm hearing what some here have suggested: that there is no absolute best cable even for a given system, and that all cables will have some shortfall that you just have to live with. We'll see.

Thanks for your continued thoughts and recommendations!
Howard
Thanks for your thoughts, guys. Paul, I'm of the same mind as you. I think I'm going to stick with what I have now, and when I move this summer I'll renew my search, starting witht the cable loan program from usedcable.com.

Thorman, I will surely try the new Poeima as well, not only because of the cable issue, but also because I've read great things about the RSA Sason speakers, and will consider purchasing them when/if I get in to a permanent home and save up enough money to buy them. Purchasing the Sason is contingent on my leaving the military, however. I'm not about to lug 140-pound speakers from duty station to duty station! :O

Thanks again for your thoughts. I'll post more to this thread this summer or fall when I start trying more cables.