In my room I've only had BAT but wonder about how it'd compare to PL, ARC, and especially Rogue. Yes replace all the tubes at the same time, else your mind will devour itself when you start hearing things that don't quite sound right. Best feature not explicitly mentioned above is 3 sets of taps to match diff't speaker impedances.
Primaluna?
I’m thinking about giving a full tube setup a go and Primaluna in particular. Looking to hear people’s experiences with Primaluna in general. My main draw to them outside of tubes is there auto bias and protective features. Wondering if people generally replace a single bad tube or if people are replacing all tubes of that type when there’s a failure. Also would be interested if there were any other companies with at least a similar protective feature. The auto bias sounds great but the protective features are a bigger deal to me.