I think the Rogue is fully balanced, is it not?
As an interim step, if not already, you could upgrade the tubes in the RP-1. I put a set of Mullards in from Andy’s tube services and have really enjoyed them. Enjoy those while you continue research on high grade pre
Also you might try the PS Audio BHK Pre. That has 12AU7 valved input stage. And you can possibly trial that unit and they give you a decent amount for the Rogue. Although you proly do better selling RP-1 on your own as people snap those up pretty quickly.