Potential Pair of Great Bookshelf Speakers for Sale!


What are they? That is the question. I have a pair of Totem Sky's that I really enjoy. But, for aesthetics, I just purchased a pair of Harbeth P3ESR's in Olivewood Ash. They look fabulous! I haven't had much time to break them in yet, but my first impression of them is positive. But I think the Totem's have more realism in the mid and low bass area. I find my ears perking up on certain music and I'm thinking to myself how great that sounds from a small'ish' speaker. And, I'm not driving them with anything spectacular. I use an NAD AVR with 60 watts per channel and that seemed to be more than enough to get that wonderful sound. Anyway, we'll see how the P3's do in the next few weeks. As to the title of this thread, I'll be selling0  one of these pairs soon. Any comments are welcome.

Ag insider logo xs@2xrongvk

Showing 2 responses by treepmeyer

I'm in a similar position.  Currently have Wharfdale Jade 3 bookshelf speakers and have been considering Harbeth P3's.  The Jade 3's are really nice in my small room but the P3's shine in the mid-range female vocals that I prefer.  Is it worth switching?  Don't know.  I may have to buy some P3's and live with them for a few months.

Driving the Jade 3's with a Cambridge CXA-81.  Better to keep the Jade's and move to a better amp or DAC?  Just don't know.  PM me if you decide to keep the Totems.

lanx0003 - Your question is spot-on.  Truth is I very much like the Jade 3's paired with the CXA81.  Only limitation is a certain muddiness or lack of crispness in the 500hz region, especially with piano music.  I'm guessing that is a room acoustics issue.  I've maxed out the WAF with a pair of tube traps, panels, heavy curtains, etc.  I purchased a miniDSP SHD streamer with Dirac Live to address remaining room issues.  The SHD is up and running but I haven't implemented Dirac Live yet. 

Yesterday I auditioned the P3's at Decibel Audio in Chicago.  The magical midrange was quite evident.  Combine that with excellent imaging and soundstage gives one great sound.  Better than the Jade 3's and worth the extra $?  I don't know yet.

Same sort of issue with the dac.  Moving from a Bluesound Node2i to the dac in the CXA81 was a major improvement, and for my use I am very satisfied with the SQ.  Why consider something else?  Well, it's the nagging feeling that even better SQ is within reach.  For example, I've read good reviews and agon comments on Chord, Denafrips and Schiit dacs, just to name a few within my price range.  Would I notice an improvement in my room with my music, etc.?  Would I consider the extra $ worthwhile?  I don't know, but over time I intend to find out.  In the meantime I will continue to enjoy the Jade 3's and the CXA81 because, as you imply, there is really nothing wrong with them.  Regards.