Portrait in Jazz - The Perfect Record?


With working from home, I've been listening mostly to digital, but this morning I decided to really sit down and listen to some records and the first one was Bill Evans' Portrait in Jazz.  I've always liked Evans' music and recordings, but this just blew me away.  As perfect as you can get as far as performance, engineering, sonics and music.  Recorded in 1959, they only had one plate reverb to use and it made everyone sound like they're in the same room.  Once the digital reverbs came out, engineers went crazy with a different reverb on everything - Hello! Different reverb = different room.  Not exactly a recipe for cohesive sonics.  IMO, this was Bill at his best with his best trio - Scott LaFaro and Paul Motion. Not that Eddie Gomez and Marty Morrell were slouches.  Far from it.  Anyway - stop reading and go fish this out of your record rack. For you digital folks, the XRCD is not bad at all.  IMO the piano sound is not as pure, but that could be because of the limitations of my digital system. 
chayro
There is no one I like more than Bill Evans, not that I admire him more than anyone else, but he's certainly up there with the best (of many) for me. He happened to grow up a few towns away from me in NJ, we've had our fair share here. Yes, what a magic trio there!
Agree - spectacular music.  I am lucky to have a very nice vinyl version in mono.   Avoids the piano on one speaker and bass/drums on the other speaker.  Side 1 is on my list of best sides of an LP. One great track followed by another.
Actually, the version I have had the piano panned center.  But every stereo BD record seems to have the drums left with the hihat full right for some reason.  They must have insisted on this because no engineer would ever pan drums like that. Makes the drums sound weird if you know what it's supposed to be.  My guess it they wanted everybody to know it was "stereo" and went for a ping-pong effect.  
I was probably thinking of my stereo version of Waltz for Debby.  Thanks for correcting me.  In any event, the music of Portrait in Jazz is perfect mono or stereo - of course in my opinion.  
They were in the same room.
That's how those albums were recorded and that's why they sound so good.