Picking speakers 3000-5000 budget

You've had some good advice and the good and bad about asking in a forum such as this as you are going to get as many suggestions as you can possibly handle. Another issue is that reviewers, especially YouTube reviewers, mainly review products from usual suspects because those companies can afford to send out review samples and pay for advertising in various rags. 

Your musical taste is pretty diverse and would require a speaker to handle harsh sounding recordings (classic rock) along with complex multitudes of instruments (classical) and then you have jazz and the acoustic music you like. While I am a fan of Magnepans, they aren't that dynamic and they are picky with amplifiers and need a lot of current. There are open baffle speakers like Spatial Audio (you can probably find the X3s for a fantastic deal) and they are large and need to be pushed out into the room. There is also the Pure Audio Project speakers and Steve Guttenberg has raved about these on his Audiophiliac channel. 

I am going to suggest Nola speakers. They might be too expensive new but there is what looks on the surface of a screaming deal here but requires local pickup although it is one state over for you in northern Ohio. The seller would also give you the opportunity to demo the speakers and to use your own gear if you wanted.

https://www.usaudiomart.com/details/650200805-nola-ko/

Here are some snippets about the speakers:

http://www.nolaspeakers.com/shows/RMAF2015/index.html

http://www.nolaspeakers.com/reviews/HPsoundings/2012-11NolaKO/index.html

Or maybe a Nola Contender or, if you want bookshelf, Boxer.

https://www.stereophile.com/content/nola-contender-loudspeaker

I had a Adcom gfa 555-2 and a Adcom gfp 565. I thought I needed new speakers because there was a harshness in the upper midrange. I have Canton ergo 80 speakers. I purchased a Rogue audio cronus dark. When I started using the Cronus dark , my Cantons lost all harshness. I added two svs 2000 pro subwoofers. Now I couldn't be happier with my system. The problem was the Adcom amp and preamp. Thr Cronus dark is vastly superior to the Adcom components. Maybe you don't need new speakers 

@dz13 

I gladly accept the problems of planar magnetic speakers because the benefits are fabulous. 

Is there a cure for phobia of box speakers? 🤔...haven’t heard it yet!

But I’m definitely open to open baffle speakers. 

gano

That's what people are saying.

Thanks

deecee

I have never heard of Aerial Acoustics.Will add it to my list.

When you see you recreate a specific concert venue,how is that done?

Are you using some kind of digital processor?

Thanks