2. analog
  3. 1293597611

Phonomena, vs PS GCPH, Others?

I've learned so much here as an observer but am going to request opinions proactively on this one. I've realized that I've over-done it in the warmth department at the expense of dynamics in my analogue chain. I recently auditioned a Musical Surroundings Phonomena II to replace my Pro-ject Tube Box II phono pre and enjoyed its dynamic extension. I dug it but a PS Audio GCPH has me wondering as I like my Digi Link iii DAC and could get one used for around the same. Are there other SS offerings that I should be looking at in this price range that would move me forward from my overly mellow presentation? Other stuff: Quad 22l2>Jolida 707a>Pro-ject Perspective TT w/ Grado Gold (could soon be switched to something like a Benz Ace).
grantd
inna
7,296 posts
 
Simaudio Moon LP3 or Lehmann could be options too. As for the cartridge, you may want to try something like Dynavector or Shelter, but I am not certain how well they would match the tonearm. You could talk to needledoctor.com or hwdsound.com especially if you are prepared to pay retail or close to it. My guess is that Dynavector would match better, but it's a guess. Benz might not be dynamic enough and do bass well enough; depends on your taste.
macdadtexas
1,794 posts
 
I have a PS Audio GCPH that's been modified by Parts Connexion and it is a world class piece of gear.

It's the best deal in audio I have ever gotten, it sounds absolutely stellar.
grantd OP
4 posts
 
Thanks for the recommendations thus far, I'll definitely be looking into them. Mac, I have a Parts Connexion modded amp that I'm really happy with as well but I don't think I can dedicate that kind of cash to the phono stage at this point. Looking to keep it closer to the Phonomena range of $600 if possible, I suppose. Going stock with a potential future upgrade could be a way to go..
vinyladdict
164 posts
 
The GCPH, stock, is a great piece of gear and worth much more than its cost in my opinion - especially if you can find one used. You can always have it upgraded in the future.

I'm sure if I heard a mod'd version I would think differently, but, I've never had the desire to have my stock GCPH mod'd in any way. It just sounds spectacular as it is and its flexibility (nice adjustments for loading and gain plus mono and phase switches) is a real stong point.
macdadtexas
1,794 posts
 
Vinyladdict, I agree whole heartedly that the PS Audio is a stellar piece of gear unmodded. Maybe the best value I have ever seen in audio.

I had budgeted $4500 for a new phono stage, coming to the conclusion after trying differnt phono stages, that it was the key ingredient, IMO, in analog playback.

I bought a modded GCPH as a stop gap while I tried many other phono stages that I auditioned from dealers, or buying used. The price of the GCPH was low enough that I knew I could resell it with very little, if any loss.

Well, every other more expensive phono stage I tried, was not any better, or as good as the GCPH. I love this thing.
More to discover