Phono Preamp Suggestions

Hi,

I am looking to upgrade to an external phono preamp. Recently, I auditioned the Rogue Ares as well as a Sim Audio Moon 310lp (no external power supply). I preferred the Sim Audio (solid state) to the Rogue (tube). 

I would like to hear from others out there that prefer a solid state preamp for a tube power amp or a tube preamp paired with a tube power amp. Why is this your preference? To me, the tube on tube was a little heavy and I thought the solid state provided balance and played well with my amp.

Additionally, I would like to know what type of difference there is between a preamp in the $1800-$2000 range such as the ones I auditioned vs. something like a Pass Labs XP15 or Whest Sig. 3. Is there a big jump from a $2K preamp to a $3K model?

Thanks,

Aaron

VPI Scout 1.1
Soundsmith Zephyr MKII
Rogue Audio Cronus Magnum (KT120)
Zu Soul MKII
Zu Cables