Analog is more emotionally engaging, since it's not music chopped into bits and reconstituted with jitter, ringing, etc. Your brain doesn't have to sort it out. Digital has gotten much better, but unless these issues are resolved on mega buck equipment, there's still a difference. I listen to both, but when you put on an lp, you sit and listen, and when you put on a cd you do other things.
One of the great things about Vinyl
Is I find myself listening to recordings all the way through.
Rarely do that with CD's and/or streaming.