If you like the sound of your CJ preamp as it is now using the stock tubes, then buying their replacement tubes will preserve that same sound.
NOS tubes should probably be tested to make sure they are still good. There is no general answer. There are some great sounding NOS tubes, and some great new tubes like the Russian made 12AX7LPS.
Anyway; the brand of NOS tubes you are most likely to hear about are going to be the good ones.