Having had a lot of Maggies over the years, I'd say that, all things being equal, bigger is better. However, newer models use slightly different technology. They do seem better top to bottom, smoother. Whether that's enough to make up for smaller panels.....Gotta let your ears decide.
BTW I still have my 1.6s also. Seems like every time I sell something, I end up regretting it. So they may live on, packed in their box.