Monitor speakers pros/cons


I am looking for general pros and cons to monitor type speakers(ie. not full range) vs the floor standing "fuller" range types. Application being 50% 2ch and 50% HT use. Price range $5000-$10k ish for the front mains. New/used this basic range.

I am wondering if to get a true sub 45hz speaker this range, one might need to spend more. Or with this price range one might be better off going with the monitor speakers. Has anybody dumped a lot of money into monitors, and if so what were the results. Also with general room limitations(less than 600sq feet) are the full size models just an honest over kill, and would the monitors interact with the room better?

Trying to learn..
Thanks
Marty
marty9876

Showing 1 response by johnnyw

Last 12 years, I've had 10 pairs of monitors and 7 pairs of floorstanders. Also used 10 different subs during this time. Until this year, the best monitor I had was the Sonus Faber Electa Amator I and the best floorstander was the Genesis APM-1. This was the only floorstander that was a TRUE full range speaker because of the built in 15" sub in each tower. All the rest needed subs to get the last octave of music or the LFE in movies.
My conclusion, you need a sub to get true full range (20Hz~20kHz) so why bother spending the money on the cabinet if you can spend it on higher quality drivers in monitors. The floorstanders are also harder to place, move, pack and ship if you decide to upgrade too. The cost of stands for monitors is minimal, particularly on Audiogon. Once you have good ones, you can keep them for all future monitors.
The REL subs are the way to go for both HT & 2ch because they have a unique Neutrik speaker level input that takes the signal from the power amp for seamless integration with the L/R speakers. It also has a line level input for the LFE channel from a HT processor that can be hooked up simultaneously.
Finally, my discovery of the year, a monitor that really goes down to 40Hz! (-1.5db, not -3 or -10db) The System Audio SA2K uses custom ScanSpeak drivers in a unique 14"Hx7"Wx12"D cabinet. Its sound bested the SF EA1 and with the REL sub beats the APM-1's. See it at http://www.system-audio.com/showpage.asp?siteid=2&id=312