Since you have phono as well as line input needs, consider a good used Audio Research SP6B preamp, or the all-tube (include regulation) SP8. The phono input on this line of Preamps was as good sounding or better than almost any other preamp of its time, and will give today's preamps a run for the money. You'll need a transformer or pre-preamp (headamp) if you are using a low-output moving coil cartridge, but if you have a good moving magnet you may forget MC forever. with this preamp. It sounds wonderful through the line stages as well. And pre-sorted tube sets for the preamps (12AX7) are available through several dealers if that appeals to you .
Modern "Vintage" Sounding Preamps
I like my current preamps (upgraded & restored Acurus LS-11 & CJ PF1) but I'm wanting something at the other end of the spectrum. My preamps, being SS, are towards the "accurate" and "clean" part of the spectrum. What preamps (tube or SS) in your experience lean heavily the soft/warm/forgiving end of the spectrum? Caveats are they must be affordable (under $2K American new or used) and less than 20 years old. Yes, I'm sure a CJ PV5 is just the ticket, but it'd need rebuilding or, if rebuilt, would push well above $2K ...