Using a Y will necessitate that you bi-wire (which for most systems is a waste of time and money in my opinion).
Considering that the amps are just refurbished I personally think your best bet is to bridge both of them. Gives you plenty of headroom and your using the speakers as intended. To any naysayers...if the amps are virtually as new or better and were designed to be bridged in the first place just go for it.
I ran ARC bridged amps for many years with no issues.
Regards,
barts